| 2011 | Saints | Colts | Steelers | Raiders | Jaguars | Brown | Falcons | Panthers | Titans | Bangels |
| 2010 | Cowboys | Colts | Cowboys | Giants | Chiefs | Chargers | Titans | Jaguars | ||
| 2009 | Saints | Jets | Jaguars | 49ers | ||||||
| 2008 | Bronco | Colts | Dolphins | Lions | Bengals | |||||
| 2007 | Bears | Cowboys | Chiefs | Colts | Titans | Saints | TampaBay | Bronco | Jaguars | |
| 2006 | Eagles | Dolphins | Jaguars | Bills | ||||||
| 2005 | Chiefs | Rams |